Tuesday, Jun 17, 2025

Megillah 26: Appropriate Use

On this daf, we find teachings about an aron hakodesh.

There was a shul with a beautiful aron kodesh. It had huge pillars that were truly magnificent. After several decades of use, it was time to remove these pillars and replace them with newer and nicer ones. The question was how to deal with the old pillars. Although our sages say that after something was sanctified, its sanctity does not just vanish, the congregants had no idea how to deal with these gigantic pillars. They could not be put into genizah due to their size, but they were also unusable for anything holy. They could, of course, be broken down and sold if there was some way to transfer their sanctity, but they were uncertain how exactly to do this.

When this question was presented to Rav Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, he gave clear instructions of what should be done: “In this instance, it is permitted to sell the pillars with the consent of the congregants and the gabbaim. They will lose their sanctity and they should purchase Tehillim for the shul with the money. Although the Biur Halacha (154:3, “Tashmishei”) reckons with the opinion that selling such items will not remove their sanctity, our case is different, since these pillars will not be usable for anything beneficial if we do not permit them. We can therefore combine the opinion of the Chavos Yair (162) that when something holy becomes utterly unusable, the holiness is removed” (Kovetz Teshuvos).

Twitter
WhatsApp
Facebook
Pinterest
LinkedIn

LATEST NEWS

Echoes of Holiness

  Once again, I was granted the zechus to spend Shavuos in Eretz Yisroel, a land where holiness is not remembered but felt, where the

Read More »

Silent Subservience

  Much has been said — and rightfully so — about the sheer magnitude of the Adirei HaTorah event. The sea of Yidden gathered in

Read More »

My Take on the News

  Polarization and Hatred Reach Record Heights Two weeks have gone by since my last column, but given the eventful nature of these times, one

Read More »

California Chaos

  Trump Orders National Guard and The Marines To Quell LA Riots Amid ICE Immigration Raids     Teaser: “The violence is escalating… It’s getting

Read More »

Digging In

IN A PERFECT WORLD Here’s an embarrassing memory from my childhood. It must have been in camp, because I was with some friends in a

Read More »

NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to stay updated