Wednesday, Jun 29, 2022

Megillah 21: Chazakah Limits?

On this daf, we find some halachos of krias haTorah.

In one town, the community’s veteran chazzan was getting older and his voice started to weaken. When people began to notice that his Torah reading was growing fainter from week to week, they finally decided to respectfully replace him with a younger candidate who had a stronger voice.

The wealthy man was annoyed with what he felt to be severe mistreatment and went to Rav Eizele Charif for justice. “Do I not have an irrefutable chazakah?” asked the man bitterly.

Rav Eizele empathized with the older man, but realized that he could not be chazzan at the cost of people being unable to hear the reading. He gently quipped, “You are mistaken. Our sages say that for a chazakah to be completely valid, it must be accompanied with a ‘kol. Although they are discussing a monetary halacha and ‘kol’ in that context means public knowledge, we can learn another lesson from this statement: a chazzan only maintains his chazakah as long as he still has a robust voice!” (Rebbi Eizele Charif).

Twitter
WhatsApp
Facebook
Pinterest
LinkedIn

LATEST NEWS

Let’s Be Better

  It was, in a sense, the first gathering of the Bnei Yisroel, the twelve pillars of our nation surrounding the bedside of their father.

Read More »

I’M JUST SAYING

When Donkeys Are Humanized and Humans Are Donkeyed   An oft-quoted Chazal describes the concept of yeridas hadoros and the spiritual law of diminishing returns.

Read More »

Disequilibrium

In a Perfect World   Imagine an exquisitely sensitive machine or instrument. If its job is to assess the strength of the wind, it will

Read More »

NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to stay updated