Wednesday, May 21, 2025

Chagigah 25: The Virtues of the Ignorant

This daf discusses which halachos we believe an am ha’aretz about.

During the war between France and Austria which began in 1809, the Chasam Sofer was suspected of espionage and forced to flee Pressburg. Once, he stayed at the home of a very generous but ignorant man. It was something of a shock to the Chasam Sofer when he heard his host slander him for no reason that he could fathom.

At the soonest opportunity, the Chasam Sofer took his host aside and asked why he had spoken against him. He was shocked by the man’s reply. “Shouldn’t I speak against a guest staying at my home who blatantly disregards halacha?” the man bluntly replied. “I saw with my own eyes how you skipped Kiddush on Shabbos morning, saying only borei pri hagafen on a cup of wine. You also sat during Kiddush. I may be simple, but I am G-d-fearing and cannot abide by people who disregard halacha.”

The Chasam Sofer patiently explained his host’s error to him until he finally comprehended that it was he who was in the wrong. Not surprisingly, he apologized to the Chasam Sofer and stopped speaking against him.

Much later, when describing this experience, the Chasam Sofer commented. “I believe this man misunderstood and slandered me as punishment for my failing to obey the dictum of our sages that one should not live in the vicinity of an am ha’aretz.”

The Chasam Sofer added that there was also a positive outcome to this experience: “I was very pleased to see this man’s steadfastness, despite his lack of learning. Having noticed the climate of heresy gearing up in the world, I was worried about the future of Torah Judaism. Witnessing this man’s stubbornness was therefore very comforting. It was wonderful to find a simple person so determined to keep every detail of his understanding of halacha. Through people like him, Torah will continue undiluted!” (Divrei Torah, gilyon 279, p. 2).

Twitter
WhatsApp
Facebook
Pinterest
LinkedIn

RELATED ARTICLES

LATEST NEWS

Our Identity

  President Donald Trump returned from a highly publicized and triumphant visit to three Arab capitals, bringing with him promises of over $1 trillion in

Read More »

IN A PERFECT WORLD

  BUILDING BLOCKS Watch a child erecting a tower. With fierce concentration he piles one wooden block on top of the next, adding height with

Read More »

My Take On The News

  Lag Ba’omer 5785: 200,000 Visitors in Meron The prodigious efforts invested in the Lag Ba’omer festivities in Meron bore fruit. Almost 200,000 people visited

Read More »

Bringing Them Up

  As Shavuos approaches, I always find myself remembering—with deep fondness—the Yomim Tovim I spent in yeshiva. Whether it was in Philadelphia, Ponovezh, or Lakewood,

Read More »

NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to stay updated